(Source by Snap Shot)
Recently , there was an incident happen regarding to Orthodox Jewish paper apologies to the White House for deleting Hilary Clinton and Audrey Tomason pictures in the newspaper during the monitoring of the raid by the navy Seals that killed Osama bin Laden. In the article, according to Di Tzeitung, it was said that the readers believed that women should be appreciated for who they are and what they do , not for what they look like. However, according to Jprof (2011), it was stated that photojournalist is replete from Lester (1999), he stated that the number two rule of the photojournalism ethic is to not change the picture. Pictures should be stand as they are shot.Jprof (2011) also state that in the code of ethics of the National Press Photographers Association, one of the ethics is that photographer have to be complete and provide full context when photographing subjects and try avoiding any form of stereotype and bias towards an individual.
The Orthodox Jewish Newspaper Version
The White House version
Reep (2006, p 153) mentioned that a photograph must be clear and focus on the pertinent item because it provides a surface view of an object or event. Therefore, i personally feel and believe that the Orthodox Jewish newspaper publisher should never have remove both Hilary Clinton and Audrey Tomason from the picture itself. Despite it is their culture that believes women should be known for what they do not what they look however they should inform that the picture is being digitally altered.
( Source by Scripps Media Ethics)
In conclusion, there are danger in manipulating a photograph especially when it is related to the White House. Lester (2011) quoted Howard Chapnick (1982) and stated that credibility and responsibility are words that give right to call photography a profession rather than a business. Therefore, photojournalists should be concerned about the consequences of manipulating a picture. This is because once the threat to credibility is irreversible, public will start to lost trust on the news photograph.
References List
1. Lester.P.M, 1999, Chapter Six : Picture Manipulations, Photojournalism An Ethical Approach, viewed on 5th November 2011, <http://commfaculty.fullerton.edu/lester/writings/chapter6.html>
2. Ivone , 2011, Role of Women In Today's Society, viewed on 5th November 2011, <http://www.polishmarriage.org/Stories/women-society.html>
3. Jprof, 2011, Photojournalism Ethics, viewed on 5th November 2011, <http://www.jprof.com/photojn/photojn-ethics.html>
3. Reep. D ( 2006), Technical Writing : Document Design , Person Publication, Ed. 6, pp 133- 172.
No comments:
Post a Comment